Video Widget

« »
‏Afghanistan Kabul Hamid Karzai NATO Taliban Hillary Clinton لیبل والی اشاعتیں دکھا رہا ہے۔ سبھی اشاعتیں دکھائیں
‏Afghanistan Kabul Hamid Karzai NATO Taliban Hillary Clinton لیبل والی اشاعتیں دکھا رہا ہے۔ سبھی اشاعتیں دکھائیں

ہفتہ، 23 اپریل، 2011

US qualms on Pakistan’s War on Terror

Stabilization in Afghanistan is a big challenge which needs lots of effort from international community. The security and stability of Pakistan is directly linked with the stability of Afghanistan, unless or until there is no peace in Afghanistan, we cannot expect peace in Pakistan. Sincere efforts are required by the regional states to bring long term viable peace in Afghanistan. The US has to change its policy in dealing with Pakistan, it has to respect and honour the sovereignty and independent stature of Pakistan.

By Alam Rind

In the continuation of “do more” syndrome Pakistan once again has been criticised by White House for its ineffectiveness against Islamic radicals. The key claim is that Pakistani Armed Forces recover territory from the control of Taliban, but fails to completely secure the area. That led to the assumption that Pakistan has no clear path to defeat insurgency. The American point of view has been sharply contested by the government and military circles. Pakistan Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman Tahmeena Janjua has asserted that “I would emphatically state that we do not share the assessment of the US.” The Americans continue to emphasise that Pakistan should disallow use of its soil by Taliban and other militants as safe haven. This rhetoric is continuously sounded to push Pakistan to launch operations in North Waziristan area. It also provides a plausible face saving excuse to US and NATO troops to cover up their failure in Afghanistan. Such mean statements only underline their disregard for the sacrifices made by the people and Armed Forces of Pakistan. Though about 147,000 Pakistani troops are in the area but what they are up against is a continuous and a streamed flow of terrorists and weapons from across the border. Under such environment complete and lasting peace cannot return to tribal areas after a one time operation. It has to be a long drawn struggle, which at one end should frustrate financers and sponsors of terrorists and on the other end induce confidence among locals as regards their safety and development of their area. Government and Armed Forces of Pakistan are well on their way towards achieving this objective. Pakistan is often blamed for not pulling troops from her eastern border to fight terrorists in the tribal areas. This is a strange argument especially once viewed in the backdrop of the facts that India is sponsoring terrorism in Pakistan from her bases in Afghanistan and critical disputes like Kashmir, Siachin and Sir Creak are yet to be resolved. Moreover peace time disposition of her army enables her to launch offensive against Pakistan at short notice. In the absence of tangible progress on resolution of disputes it certainly won’t be possible for Pakistan to overlook Indian capabilities for presumed friendly and positive intention. A common Pakistani would be reluctant to trust Americans either. It is so due to awful remarks by senior American politicians like Congressman Gary Ackerman who proposed that Pakistan should be abandoned as it is about to go broke or collapse. In a congressional discussion Mr. Ackerman remarked “so if we gave another $20 billion, I guess, would they like us in the morning - (laughter) - as we gave $20 billion through another night?” are mean by any standard. How on the earth they think that a self-respecting Pakistani would like them once they equate Pakistan and its people to a prostitute. To a common Pakistani, Americans are not sincere. They want to use Pakistan for their own end that is evident from Raymond Davis case, drone attacks that result in killing of innocent civilians and blatant contempt for Pakistan exhibited by seasoned politicians like Mr. Ackerman. Americans certainly need Pakistan to sustain their operations and to create enabling environment for their respectable exit from war-torn Afghanistan. During the last nine years they have been beating the shadow of al-Qaeda and mutilating local populace. Their COIN operations totally failed and they have had limited success in building governmental structure and security forces of Afghanistan. The biggest blunder was committed when President Obama announced that exit of US troops from Afghanistan will start from July 2011. According to Wall Street Journal al-Qaeda has started returning to Afghanistan. Thanks to the stupidity of Pastor Terry Jones, Taliban and other freedom fighters have regained public support. Afghanistan has witnessed severe public backlash and tempers are high against US and NATO personnel. Under such circumstances Americans need Pakistan more than ever before. US and Pakistan need to revitalise their relations to overcome recent bad patch. Few positive statements may be able to dispel present irritants. However, lasting relations can only be built through mutual respect. Americans can turn public opinion in their favour by helping resolve Kashmir dispute. It is a well established fact that peace in subcontinent will best serve interests of America, India and Pakistan and those of the people of the region. It is in the fitness of things that all the stakeholders exert to bridge gaps between the countries for mutual good and for the prosperity of the people.

ہفتہ، 9 اپریل، 2011

President Karzai’s dilemma

President Karzai`s tirade of the Afghan Taliban`s sanctuaries in Pakistan has become too trite,too obsolete and too puerile an idiom to stand. If there is no indigenous militancy and insurgency problem, who then are the ISAF and his own forces fighting in the villages and cities of Afghanistan?




By Muhammad Jamil

President Hamid Karzai, while visiting the families of civilians killed in Asadabad, the capital of Kunar province, urged foreign troops to get out of Afghanistan and take their fight across the border into Pakistan. This is an effort to deflect the failure of the NATO and Afghan forces and to blame Pakistan for all the mess in Afghanistan. One of the reasons for his frustration is that the US and Britain are poised to stop aid to Afghanistan if corruption is not rooted out. He, in fact, is facing a dilemma. In the event the US forces leave or are forced to leave, he does not stand any chance to remain at the helm. And if the Americans decide to stay on for an indefinite period, he will continue drawing flak from his compatriots for the loss of innocent lives in NATO strikes or the heinous acts of those who kill Afghans for sport. American army specialist Jeremy Morlock, 23, pleaded guilty in a US military court on March 23, admitting that he was part of a “kill team” that deliberately murdered Afghan civilians for sport between January and May last year. Though ISAF commanders claim that there is modest progress, the overall situation in Afghanistan is grim, which has been admitted in a recent report.

The semi-annual White House report to Congress to judge progress or otherwise on key objectives of the war in Afghanistan and operations against al Qaeda in Pakistan, has stated that Pakistan lacks a robust plan to defeat the Taliban. The report notes a deterioration of the situation in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) in the country’s northwest along the Afghan border between January and March this year. The report however acknowledges that “tremendous human sacrifices” were made by Pakistani forces in the region, but concludes that, “what remains vexing is the lack of any indication of ‘hold’ and ‘build’ planning or staging efforts to complement ongoing clearing operations”. The problem is that they are neither willing to address Pakistan’s concerns nor do they realise that Pakistan’s military is already overstretched, and if the military operation is extended to other areas, it could prove counter-productive. As regards their claim that the Taliban or Haqqani group are operating from Pakistan, one can question them as to what they are doing on the other side of the border. Why do they not kill the militants while they cross the Pak-Afghan border?

 Afghans in general are tired of continued foreign troops’ presence on the Afghan soil. They have suffered death and destruction since the 1970s when Soviet forces invaded, followed by a civil war and then a pounding by the US and allied forces since the ouster of the Taliban. They vent their anger in different ways. They came out onto the streets in droves to protest the Quran’s desecration by Pastor Terry Jones. What seemingly is upsetting for the NATO forces is that the protests broke out in places like Mazar-i-Sharif, Herat and Kabul — three of the seven regions that President Hamid Karzai identified for the first transfer of security from the coalition forces to the Afghan army and police. Their contention that these demonstrations have been incited by the Taliban is tantamount to a self-confession that the Taliban are still a force to reckon with and not on the run, as their military commanders have been projecting ever since the troops surge. Mazar-i-Sharif is warlord Abdul Rashid Dostum’s stronghold, Herat is another warlord Ismail Khan’s redoubt, and violent demonstrations in those areas bespeak greatly of the Taliban’s persistent influence.

Meanwhile, debate is raging in the US over troop withdrawals from Afghanistan this summer. But military leaders and President Barack Obama’s civilian advisers are at odds as far as the size and pace of the planned pullout of US troops is concerned. The Pentagon stands for a token drawdown, say 5,000 from the combat forces, whereas the Obama administration is pressing for a massive withdrawal as promised. President Obama would like to see the withdrawal of 30,000 additional troops that were sent on the military commanders’ demand. In fact, the American public is wary of the war’s cost, which is around $ 120 billion this year. According to recent opinion polls, 75 percent of the people want a quick withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan, as they feel that they will have to bear the brunt of the prolonged war.

Seeing the public mood, even Republicans, who till as recently as February 2011 were against the drawdown, have changed their stance because they have to go to the people for votes next year. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s about-face is quite obvious. She has been talking about three preconditions for starting negotiations with the Taliban: a) they renounce violence and dissociate from al Qaeda; b) lay down arms, and c) accept the existing constitution. More recently, she said those were “not preconditions” but “negotiable objectives”. There have been rumours about talks being held, courtesy Saudi Arabia, but the Taliban have always refuted such news and have said that they will not enter into any negotiations unless the foreign troops are withdrawn. After the surge in troops and operations in Marjah and Helmand, ISAF commanders seem to be satisfied with the progress, but to independent observers and analysts, there is not much to write home about. On the face of it, the process of the drawdown of foreign occupation forces and transfer of security responsibility to the Afghan army and police has been set in motion to start by the middle of this year and to complete by 2014, but according to Secretary Defence Robert Gates, it will depend on the situation prevailing at that time.

Let us presume that they will go ahead according to schedule. But can President Karzai imagine what an Afghan army comprising Tajiks and Hazaras would mean after the transition in the Pashtun regions, as there is chronic Pashtun-Tajik antipathy and Pashtun-Hazara loathing? President Karzai should come to terms with the harsh ground realities. His tirade of the Afghan Taliban’s sanctuaries in Pakistan has become too trite, too obsolete and too puerile an idiom to stand. If there is no indigenous militancy and insurgency problem, who then are the ISAF and his own forces fighting in the villages and cities of Afghanistan, not just in the south or east but also in the far-flung north and west? President Karzai, instead of the blame game, should get into serious negotiations with the Taliban, as the only way forward is to give fuller representation to the country’s Pashtun majority. This will help him bring his war-torn nation to peace, security and stability. Indeed, the American military commanders would act very wisely if they put their full weight behind their political leadership’s latest moves for a political solution involving peace negotiations with the Taliban and other insurgent groups.

The writer is a freelance columnist. He can be reached at mjamil1938@hotmail.com

منگل، 23 نومبر، 2010

Afghanistan: NATO’s mission impossible

 The people of Afghanistan are suffering, while NATO soldiers die on daily basis, and there are other signs that the mighty NATO has miseraby failed in Afghanistan.
_________________________________________________

By Shiraz Paracha


During the weekend, leaders of 28 NATO countries gathered in Lisbon, Portugal, for a face-saving meeting as it became clear that the Western military alliance could face a humiliating defeat in one of the world’s poorest countries.
Contrary to the NATO’s official statement about providing security in Afghanistan as long as it takes, the NATO commanders know that the longer they stay in Afghanistan, the deeper their troubles would become in the war zone as well as at home fronts.
In 2005, NATO sent thousands of troops to Afghanistan to support the US occupation amid tall claims about the “noble Afghan mission” and how it would bring peace and security to Afghanistan.

Five years on, peace and stability are distant dreams in Afghanistan. The security situation has worsened under the NATO control. The foreign occupation has brought further death and destruction to the country. The people of Afghanistan are suffering, while NATO soldiers die on a daily basis, and there are other signs that the mighty NATO has miserably failed in Afghanistan.
One aim of NATO gathering in Lisbon was to find a way out of Afghanistan. The reality is that the Afghan mission was wrong from the outset. NATO's presence in Afghanistan violates the organisation's own charter and the heavy Afghan engagement is beyond NATO's basic mandate.

It was apparent that Afghans would never accept foreign troops, especially Western forces, on their land, but NATO forced its agenda upon the UN and instead of involving the wider world, particularly Muslim states and neighbours of Afghanistan, the West took direct charge of Afghanistan at gunpoint.
It is possible that building peace and security was just the stated purpose of the military intervention in Afghanistan, and the actual and wider aim of the Afghan mission could be taking control of vital energy routes out of Central Asia. Perhaps encircling China and Russia could be another reason for the NATO Afghan misadventure.
It was amusing and ironic, however, to observe NATO leaders flattering Russia, a country that NATO intended to defeat and destroy. After all, 61 years ago, the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation was created to counter Moscow's global influence. Interestingly, in 2010, NATO leaders were inflated when president of the proud and strong Russia granted the Lisbon gathering an audience and agreed that his country could consider cooperating with NATO.

At the Portuguese capital, the most 'advanced and civilised' nations again lied to their public almost in the same way as they did back in 1949 when NATO was established. Back then, a manufactured hysteria about the Soviet threat led to the creation of NATO.
During the Cold War, Europe and the United States exaggerated the Soviet military threat and justified the existence of NATO. But when the Cold War ended in 1991, NATO lost its purpose and became irrelevant.
To date, no country on earth can match the US military might. Europe is not under threat by a state or states; however, warmongering Western leaders and generals are looking for new and perceived enemies to continue the fear game. The war and weapons industry also want to keep the 'White Elephant', therefore the capitalist world is, now, inventing threats to justify the otherwise redundant NATO to maintain the Western military hegemony.

In the middle of the Second World War, Britain and the United States were drawing the contours of the Cold War. Together, they plotted against their own ally, the Soviet Union. Western countries considered the Communist Soviet Union as a bigger threat to the capitalist system than the Nazi Germany.
A careful and detailed strategy to counter the Soviet Union was in play during the war years. The main target of the 1941 Atlantic Charter was the Soviet Union. The Anglo-American leaders had created the Charter to defeat the Communist threat. It was based on certain freedoms - freedom of thought and expression, freedom from want, freedom of religion and freedom of movement. These freedoms were boosted as the founding principles of the Western Free World by then US president Franklin D Roosevelt and then British prime minister Winston Churchill. The underlying message was that the Western world was the beacon of hope and prosperity and was superior to Communist countries where no such freedoms existed.

The 1941 Charter was a calculated move to stab the Soviet Union and sabotage her image and credibility at a time when the USSR was already a Western ally. It was the Soviet Union which took the real brunt in the Second World War. More than 25 million Soviet troops and citizens lost their lives at the hand of Germans but at the end it was Stalin's strong policies and Soviets' bravery that Germany was defeated. However, the West never really recognised the Soviet role in the Second World War. On the contrary, the West stole the credit for winning the war from the Soviet Union.
The United Nations was established in 1945 to protect and pursue Anglo-American interests. The 1941 Atlantic Charter was the base of the UN and the West wanted to use the international body to discredit the Soviet Union and indeed the whole Communist-Socialist model. It is another matter that a decade later, newly independent states from the developing world started joining the United Nations and Western countries became a minority. Nevertheless, the West tried to undermine the UN General Assembly and manipulated the UN through the Security Council.
When the socialist revolution occurred in China and from East Europe to East Asia Communist and Socialist ideas gained popularity, the West openly launched a new war against the Communist Bloc. It was a Cold War mainly because the Soviets, too, had developed the nuclear capability and it was impossible to bulldoze the USSR by a military conflict.
The start of the Cold War is also interesting. In the late 1940s, Churchill, who was rejected by the British public in elections, was sitting at home but was hungry for a role in international politics. A depressed and angry Churchill was missing the limelight that he had become used to during the war years. He saw himself as a statesman and a saviour of Britain but the ‘thankless’ Britons sent him home exactly at the time when he returned to Britain after ‘winning’ the war.
Shrewd and opportunist Churchill used the Soviet threat as an opportunity for his return to the international political stage. He became the drumbeater of the Communist threat. It was Churchill who had coined the term 'iron curtain' in a speech at a US university.
The launch of the Cold War gave birth to NATO. For the following 40 years, the world was divided between the Good and the Evil and NATO was on the side of the Good. It was a defender of democracy and freedom. It was a guaranter of Western security and from a Western perspective, NATO protected the civilised world. It was simple and easy as the world was seen in black and white. The organised propaganda through the Western media presented NATO and the West on a 'high moral ground'.
But in 1991, all that ended abruptly with the smooth and peaceful split of the Soviet Union. The West painted the Soviet demise as its victory. But in fact, it was the biggest shock for the huge Western military and propaganda machine.
The Cold War mindset was not ready to accept the new change. The mysterious attacks in the United States on September 11, 2001 and the subsequent 'war on terror' filled the enemy vacuum for the Cold War warriors, but it did not help an organisation like NATO that was created on the concept of traditional warfare.
In the post-1945 era, despite their technological superiority and military and economic power, Western countries did not fight directly against powerful states. Proxy wars were the West's preferred method throughout the Cold War period.
Nevertheless, in the 1990s, the West opted for military interventions and regime changes. Western countries acted as a pack of wolves and attacked small and weak states. The strategy provided an opportunity to lightweights such as Bush and Blair to imitate Churchill and Roosevelt and appear strong and victorious.
But the US defeat in Iraq and the NATO's failed mission in Afghanistan have proven that military occupations and interventions are counterproductive and expose weaknesses of occupiers and aggressors.
Today, NATO is disillusioned and disoriented. It is demanding from its member states to allocate at least two percent of their GDPs to defence budgets. In a desperate effort to keep its large and bureaucratic structures and huge budget, NATO has been adding vague, unrealistic and ambiguous aims and objectives to its mission. It has committed blunders like Afghanistan but its commanders did not seem to have learned any lessons.
Regardless of the Lisbon rhetoric, not all NATO member states can afford ever-increasing military budgets to counter open-ended threats and fight unspecified enemies. Weakening European economies need trade and investment rather than wars. They rely on energy but the energy sources are out of Europe. Skilled labour and markets are beyond the geographical sphere of the most NATO states. And most NATO countries certainly do not have the will and capacity for missions impossible, like the one in Afghanistan.

Shiraz Paracha is a journalist and analyst. He can be reached at: shiraz_paracha@hotmail.com

منگل، 20 جولائی، 2010

The Kabul Conference



"I remain determined that our Afghan national security forces will be responsible for all military and law enforcement operations throughout our country by 2014,"
Karzai told representatives from 70 organisation and states.




By: Bassam Javed


As a sequel to the International Conference on Afghanistan in London on 28 January this year, around seventy representatives from around the globe will gather again in Kabul on 20 July to have an appraisal on the progress made in light of the decisions taken therein in London. The delegates would represent their respective governments, international/regional organizations and financial institutions to deliberate and endorse an Afghan government led plan for improved governance, development, security and stability in Afghanistan.

Since the London Conference a lot of development has taken place in Afghanistan. The highlight has been the ‘Afghan Jirga’ on 2nd June that reassured many Afghans about the aim of reconciliation and that the effort really does need their support. The special representative of the UN Secretary General while briefing the Security Council on the situation in Afghanistan last month emphasized the importance of maintaining resilience in the year ahead, with events like Peace Jirga, the Kabul Conference itself as a follow-up of the London Conference and September’s parliamentary elections, all indicated that major political aims streamlined for Afghanistan were broadly on track. Security during the conference will be one issue that consistently remains under review by Afghan Army Corp 111 based in Kabul, Afghan Police, NATO and ISAF.

The forth coming parliamentary elections coming at the heels of the much touted fraudulent presidential elections have gathered much significance as they would gauge the political awakening of Afghans. Concurrently, The United Nations has worked with the international community in charting out the ‘implementation guidelines’ for the elections. The guidelines have already their impact where we have recently seen a change of personalities in the Election Commission’s hierarchy. Similarly, the guidelines would ensure that 68 seats for the women are accounted for and that two international commissioners would be appointed to oversee the complaints with an authority to concur the results or otherwise. The number of candidates that have filed their nominations is quite convincing of the political reawakening as 2677 candidates including 400 Afghan women contest for a seat in the parliament.

A series of meetings of the foreign based envoys in Afghanistan have also been held to deliberate the outcome of various efforts put in by the International community to stabilize Afghanistan. First it was held in Abu Dhabi in January this year where 30 envoys represented their countries and the second one took place in the Spanish capital with the same number of envoys. The donor countries at the Spanish moot called Afghanistan to ensure that the funds donated by them do not end up in wrong hands. They also desired the reconciliation plan ‘up and running’ before the Kabul conference to show progress. There are a lot of expectations from the forth coming Conference.
The year 2010 as such has been unarguably touted to be the most crucial year for the future of Afghanistan. With the passage of time since 2001, the understanding of Afghan dynamics has made the international stakeholders in Afghanistan realize that no military solution will solve the Afghan crises. Instead of accumulating endless number of military boots on the ground to launch an offensive in Qandahar the best strategy for the NATO and ISAF would be to shift their focus in enabling Afghans create a vision for Afghanistan that could be pursued by themselves. The Conference would be attended by the foreign ministers including the US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and the UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon besides other foreign ministers and high officials. The main objective of the Conference would be to foster confidence in the public contract between the Afghan Government and its people in delivering social and economic improvement. However, there are a few countries that have feasted and made hay in Afghanistan while the NATO and ISAF concentrated to stabilize Afghanistan. India for one that will still throw spanners in the proceedings of the conference by trying to dent international communities resolve to stabilize Afghanistan and hand-over the security responsibilities to Afghans before a phased withdrawal of US and NATO forces commences. Having managed to implement its agenda in Afghanistan while NATO and ISAF forces sought and fought the Taliban, India now fears that it would not be able to implement its complete agenda to destabilize Pakistan using the Afghan soil, if an early withdrawal takes place. Taking a cue from the American phrase of being either with us or against us, India will try to press participating countries to choose between the two countries. If it is Pakistan they will not get India’s massive defense orders and a share in its booming economy which has always been used to gain political and diplomatic advantages.

Tags: